PetSecur Logo
HomeToolsBreed comparison

Coton de Tulear vs German Shepherd

Discover the differences between Coton de Tulear and German Shepherd to make the best choice for your situation.

Try different breeds

vs
Coton de Tulear
Madagascar

Coton de Tulear

Non-Sporting Group
Small

A cheerful, affectionate companion with a cotton-like coat and lively spirit. Loves bonding with families and thrives on human attention and playful interaction.

German Shepherd
Germany

German Shepherd

Herding Group
Large

Confident, loyal, and highly intelligent, this breed thrives as both a devoted family companion and a reliable working partner. Always alert and eager to learn, it adapts to many roles with ease.

Quick comparison

Size:

Small

Male:

4–6 kg

Coat:

Long, cotton-like

Lifespan:

14–16 years

Female:

3.5–5 kg

Energy:

Moderately active

Size:

Large

Male:

30–40 kg

Coat:

Double coat, dense undercoat

Lifespan:

9–13 years

Female:

22–32 kg

Energy:

High energy

Personality & behavior

Compare the personality traits and behavioral characteristics of both breeds.

Coton de Tulear

Friendliness
5/5

Very affectionate and enjoys companionship with people

Intelligence
4/5

Learns commands quickly and easily understands routines

Energy Level
3/5

Moderate activity needs; enjoys short daily walks

Playfulness
5/5

Loves interactive games and playful activities

Adaptability
4/5

Adjusts well to new environments and routines

German Shepherd

Friendliness
4/5

Warm with family, reserved with strangers

Intelligence
5/5

Quick learner, highly trainable and alert

Energy Level
5/5

Needs regular activity and vigorous exercise

Playfulness
4/5

Enjoys games, interactive and engaging

Adaptability
4/5

Adjusts well to new situations and environments

Care needs

Exercise, grooming, and daily care requirements

Coton de Tulear

Grooming:
High grooming needs (daily)
Exercise:
30–45 minutes daily
Shedding:
Light shedding
Trainability:
Quick learner
Climate tolerance:
Comfortable in temperate climates, sensitive to cold
Health concerns:

Patellar luxation, progressive retinal atrophy

German Shepherd

Grooming:
Average grooming needed (2–3 times weekly)
Exercise:
90–120 minutes daily
Shedding:
Heavy shedding
Trainability:
Highly trainable
Climate tolerance:
Tolerates cold well, struggles with heat
Health concerns:

Hip dysplasia, elbow dysplasia

Suitability

How well each breed fits different living situations and families

Coton de Tulear

First-time Owner
5/5

Highly suitable

Easygoing temperament and trainability make them manageable for first-time owners.

Apartment Living
5/5

Perfect fit

Small size and quiet nature suit apartment environments well.

Active Lifestyle
3/5

Moderately suitable

Enjoy play but may not match very high activity levels.

Kids
5/5

Very friendly

Gentle and tolerant with children when properly socialized.

Multiple Pets
4/5

Good companion

Usually gets along with other pets if introduced appropriately.

Being Left Alone
2/5

Prone to anxiety

Does not tolerate being left alone for extended periods.

German Shepherd

First-time Owner
2/5

Challenging for beginners

Needs experienced, consistent training and socialization

Apartment Living
2/5

Not ideal

Needs space and frequent exercise to prevent boredom

Active Lifestyle
5/5

Perfect fit

Thrives with active owners who can provide daily physical and mental challenges

Kids
4/5

Highly suitable

Loyal and protective, can be gentle and patient with proper socialization

Multiple Pets
4/5

Usually compatible

Can get along with other pets if raised together and well socialized

Being Left Alone
1/5

Prone to anxiety

Dislikes being left alone for long periods and may develop behavioral issues

Breed strengths

What each breed excels at and their best qualities

Coton de Tulear

  • Affectionate with family members
  • Generally good with children
  • Low-shedding, hypoallergenic coat
  • Adaptable to apartment living
  • Eager to please and trainable

German Shepherd

  • Highly intelligent and quick to learn tasks
  • Strong loyalty to family members
  • Excellent working and service dog abilities
  • Protective instincts make them good guardians
  • Adaptable to various training activities

Challenges & considerations

Potential challenges and considerations for each breed

Coton de Tulear

  • Prone to separation anxiety when left alone
  • Requires regular coat grooming and maintenance
  • Can be reserved with strangers
  • May bark frequently if not trained
  • Sensitive to harsh corrections

German Shepherd

  • Prone to hip and elbow dysplasia
  • High exercise needs require daily activity
  • Can develop separation anxiety if left alone
  • May be wary of strangers without socialization
  • Heavy seasonal shedding requires frequent grooming

Ready to choose your perfect breed?

Learn more about each breed or compare other breeds to find the perfect match for your lifestyle.

Discover more helpful tools

Make use of our other free tools to get the most out of your pet experience

Name Generator

Find the perfect name for your new furry friend with our smart generator

Breed Generator

Discover new and interesting breeds that could be perfect for you

Dog Quiz

Test your knowledge about dogs with our interactive quiz

Get your free pet insurance quote in 2 minutes!

Join pet owners who save money while keeping their furry friends protected

✓ Highest payouts in Netherlands ✓ No waiting period ✓ Quick claims processing

* Required fields

No obligations • Free consultation • Response within 24 hours